Burnham Seals Food, Carbon and Youth Deals in Brussels, but the EU Ties Them to Student Fees

Estimated read time 5 min read

Andy Burnham has taken Britain’s biggest step back towards Europe since Brexit. At a summit in Brussels on Friday, the prime minister and EU leaders signed three agreements covering food and farm trade, carbon markets and a youth mobility scheme, in what the Guardian described as the deepest move towards closer ties since the UK left the bloc.

“This is a good day for Britain and this is a good day for Europe,” Burnham told reporters after the talks, calling the package a “win-win”. Yet the celebrations came with a catch. The EU has signalled that none of the three deals will be adopted until Britain agrees to let European students pay the same university fees as domestic students, and the two sides have given themselves six months to settle it.

What was agreed

The centrepiece is a common sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) area, which will scrap most of the certificates and border checks that have weighed on food, animal and plant trade since 2021. According to the government’s own explainer, exporters will no longer need Export Health Certificates for goods moving between Great Britain and the EU, saving up to £200 per certificate, while phytosanitary certificates (around £25 each) and inspection fees of at least £127.60 per load will also go. Fresh sausages, burgers, seed potatoes and molluscs will regain access to the EU market, and pet owners will be able to use a multi-use pet passport instead of a new health certificate for every trip.

The government says the SPS deal is worth up to £5.1bn a year by 2040, adding up to 0.14% to GDP. The background is stark: the same document notes that UK agrifood exports to the EU have fallen by 32.5% since 2019. The agreement is due to apply from 1 March 2028.

The second deal links the UK Emissions Trading Scheme with the EU’s carbon market, with a target start date of 1 January 2028. Crucially for heavy industry, the linkage exempts British goods from the EU’s Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism, a levy that would otherwise have applied to nearly £6.5bn of UK exports. Officials estimate the link could add nearly £3.8bn a year to the economy by 2040.

The third is a Youth Experience Scheme letting 100,000 young people from each side live, work, study, volunteer or travel for up to three years. The joint statement says both sides aim to apply it no later than 2028, with places available by January 2030. Britain had originally proposed a cap of 50,000 but accepted 100,000, EU diplomats told RTÉ. The UK will also rejoin Erasmus+ in 2027.

Burnham said the combined package, first set in motion under Keir Starmer, would add 0.5% to GDP, a boost of around £17bn. He said legislation would go before parliament next week, insisting: “The deal is done. It is there in black and white in front of you.”

The tuition fee trap

The sticking point is money for universities. EU students currently pay full international fees in Britain, often several times what home students pay. A confidential EU declaration seen by the Guardian states that the bloc will not adopt the three agreements before negotiations conclude “providing for equal treatment on tuition fees”.

Ursula von der Leyen, the European Commission president, sought to calm nerves, saying she was “confident we are going to find a solution”. The European Council president, António Costa, called the UK “our closest neighbour, a reliable ally and a natural partner”.

Rule-taker row

The food and carbon deals rest on dynamic alignment, meaning Britain will apply EU rules as they change. British experts will be invited to relevant EU meetings, but the UK will have no vote. That has handed the opposition its main line of attack. Kemi Badenoch said the deal “isn’t fair” and fails to address the problems the country faces, according to the BBC. Nigel Farage, who staged a rival press conference in Brussels, said it contradicted Labour’s manifesto and amounted to a “very good day for the EU”, accusing Brussels of using the moment to “strongarm the British prime minister over tuition fee cuts”.

Burnham turned the challenge back on his rivals, arguing the agreements would mean cheaper food and electricity and faster growth. “Why would anybody turn their back on that?” he asked.

Limits of the reset

Burnham, who said on Monday it was an “obvious truth” that Britain had lost more than it gained from Brexit, was careful not to promise more. “What we are announcing today is probably the limit of what we can achieve in this parliament, given what needs to be done to implement it,” he said. A so-called brainstorming process on future options, he added, would only “inform the next parliament”.

That leaves the next general election, due by mid-2029, shaping up as a contest over Europe. Labour will campaign on cheaper food and open doors for the young. Reform and the Conservatives will campaign on sovereignty. And all of it hinges first on a six-month fight over what a French or Polish student pays to study in Manchester.

Featured image: A DFDS ferry leaves Dover Port, by Ian S, via Wikimedia Commons / Geograph, licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0.

+ There are no comments

Add yours